Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Al Christie's avatar

By the way, speaking of Hanford, what was the story on that closure? I seem to remember something about leakage into the Columbia River drainage.

Expand full comment
David MacQuigg's avatar

As you may know, there is a big debate on whether SMRs will create more nuclear waste. Citizendium's Debate Guide on Nuclear Waste Management features a report from the National Academy of Sciences claiming that the waste volume will increase by "factors of 2 to 30".

https://citizendium.org/wiki/Nuclear_waste_management/Debate_Guide#Increased_waste_from_Small_Modular_Reactors

Jack's rebuttal was excellent, but now the anti-nukers at skeptical science dot com are claiming what NAS really meant was not the waste from spent fuel, but the irradiated steel. That was not at all clear in my brief reading of the report. I have added a section on this issue to the Debate Page, but I think it could use a better response. Can't all this steel be recycled for new reactors? Why should any of it go to a landfill?

https://citizendium.org/wiki/Nuclear_waste_management/Debate_Guide#Non-fuel_waste

Maybe someone in the choir can write a better rebuttal, if Jack doesnn't have time.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts