It's the system, not the people
A colleague of mine commenting on the Centrus piece, writes
Jack,
I think this piece is wrong-headed.
There is an odor of clever conspiracy and direct corruption that permeates the article. I disagree with the spin.
The DOE nuclear stuff is no different than traditional military contracting (albeit by chance a bit worse and a bit better at times). Look at the LCS program for example.
Few here are clever enough to be conspiratorial. They are just embedded in a politically constructed system protected from industrial competition where ordinary folks doing ordinary things end up doing stunningly stupid things. Yet, no politician or congressional committee is persistent enough to change.
Your piece conjures up too much evil and conspiracy, and not nearly enough banality and inertia
He’s right. Obviously, his comments apply to the Hanford and other clean up boondoggles as well. They also apply to the NRC. Most of the rank and file at the NRC are not anti-nuclear. They went into nuclear power because they believed in it. But they have been put into a situation where nuclear power cannot be too safe. They too are just responding to the incentives that we have given them.
A corollary is that changing the people will not solve the problem. We must change the system.
Reinhold Niebuhr wrote “The problem of the age is not imposing morality on the individual, but imposing morality on the organization,” Niebuhr was not talking about the nuclear establishment, but he could have been.
I do fault top management at regulators such as NRC and EPA for lack of LEADERSHIP. Nuclear power provides the means to address climate change, lower energy costs, and end global energy poverty; the commissioners must know this. Congress did not write LNT and ALARA rules -- the NRC and EPA did! The commissioners signed off on the regulations. They have the power to change them; they are not stuck in the system.
Eisenhower showed leadership besides commanding the war in Europe; he created the US Interstate highway system. Kennedy leadership created the Moon landing; he also supported nuclear power. Love him or hate him, Fauci displayed leadership in the fog of Covid war.
We populate NRC with lawyers, who are experts that FOLLOW the laws and regulations. We don't need followers, we need leaders.
Fair enough but when a research university (Abilene Christian Univ.) has to spend $1 billion on its NRC application and include 12,000 pages of submittals for a molten salt SMR then whether you chalk it up to conspiracy or banality or inertia it has to change. Fast.